"One should put themselves in the shoes of an opponent of the project" - Mayor Elect Harry Kim
By TOM HASSLINGER West Hawaii Today October 13, 2016
KAILUA-KONA — It could be a symbol of unity, a structure that represents mankind’s desire to learn.
But should the Thirty Meter Telescope come to fruition atop Mauna Kea, telescope supporters will need to be more understanding of those who don’t want to see the project built on the mountain.
“You have to change your way of how you approach the messenger,” Hawaii County Mayor-elect Harry Kim told a room full of Rotary Club of Kona Sunrise members Wednesday morning at Humpy’s Big Island Alehouse in Kailua-Kona. “It’s a simple statement of, ‘We were wrong. We will be better.’ That’s where we must go.”
One should put themselves in the shoes of an opponent of the project, Kim told the breakfast crowd. Instead of just saying they understand where that side is coming from, truly learn about the history and beliefs of those who oppose the project.
“It’s a special gift to the people of this world,” Kim said of the mountain on which the state-of-the art telescope was slated for construction before protests and a court ruling eventually postponed it. “When you use this gift, please remember that 99 percent of the people on this island, when they look at Mauna Kea, it’s not as a place of science, they look at it because, some for the majesticness of its beauty, but for many, it’s part of their soul.”
Kim, a former two-term mayor and county Civil Defense administrator who won back the mayoral post in the August primary election, said he was speaking to the group from his own personal view, not as mayor-elect or representative of the county. He did touch on the mayor’s post, saying he’ll hawk-eye the budget once he gets into office and joked about the Rotary’s speaking guidelines that dissuade speakers from discussing politics.
But the message was mostly Mauna Kea.
Since Kim won his seat, he’s met with six different groups representing project stakeholders from France, China, the United States, India and Japan — people who have contributed $170 million to see the TMT through.
His message to them was the same: Understanding and communication.
Kim relayed one story where he was talking to an invested person about the telescope when he asked how much that person knew about why some protesters — who believe the mountain sacred and see it as a place of historic significance where ancestors are buried — were protesting. Specifically, Kim asked the person how much they knew about the State Historic Preservation Division’s Burial Council.
Not much, the person said.
“That’s the problem,” Kim said. “You’re telling them you understand and you don’t know about the sacred ground, the people’s heritage.”
The burial council was created in the late 1980s after a bulldozer working to renovate a major hotel on Maui unearthed between 900 and 1,000 Hawaiian graves, Kim said. Think of how many revered sites were disturbed before that. Queen Kaahumanu Highway was built in the 1970s; most of Kona before the 1980s, too.
“You don’t know how this offended a culture?” Kim said he told the person. “If you want to proceed on where we go from here to there — to create a very beautiful symbol of world peace of world togetherness, a quest for knowledge to make us a better people — then you better learn.”
Now, he said, imagine the shoe was on the other foot.
“I want you to put yourself in that position. This is your heritage,” he said. “This isn’t about Mauna Kea, this is symbolic of our total disrespect, disregard and on how we’re treated, a culture, a past.”
The $1.4 billion project is currently in a contest case hearing in Hilo. The state Supreme Court ruled in December the petitioners’ due process rights were violated because the state Board of Land and Natural Resources voted in favor of granting the project a land-use permit before the first contested case was held, prompting a do-over of the quasi-judicial hearing.
Regardless of what happens in the contested case, the sides will need to come together, Kim said. With better understanding, which includes learning more about Hawaiian history, the rift can mend. And, with good fortune, he said, the project will be built and represent the ideals of unity.
“A symbol on the mountain,” Kim said, that “everyone can see and every person who comes to this island can see a symbol of mankind, of working together, in the quest for knowledge, a quest for knowledge to make us a better people and better stewards of this island.”
Email Tom Hasslinger at firstname.lastname@example.org.